Today’s reading recounts two disasters that beset David’s reign. The first was a famine, the second a plague. While occasional droughts were common in arid Israel, three successive years of drought , which brought severe famine conditions definitely captured King David attention. He quickly recognized that God was punishing Israel. When he inquired of God he discovered that it was because his predecessor, Saul had broken a centuries-old non-aggression treaty with the Gibeonites. You might remember that this treaty was made by Joshua (Joshua 15:9), who was tricked by the neighboring Gibeonites into making peace even though God had told him to annihilate all the surrounding peoples. Because of their treachery, Joshua allowed them to live but made them virtual slaves to the people of Israel.
When David discerned that God’s anger was because of Saul’s murderous rampage against the Gibeonites, he asked them what they wanted him to do about the breach of the treaty. Initially, they responded humbly saying that they were mere slaves and shouldn’t expect to have a say in the matter. When pressed by David they asked for the lives of seven of Saul’s descendants.
To our 21st century minds this request seems totally unfair and heinous; why should grandsons die for the sin of the grandfather. However their request was completely consistent with the Law’s demand of an “eye for eye”. In fact, they could have asked for many more lives but the request for the death of seven of Saul’s descendants seems to be a symbolic Gibeonite gesture to try to ”bury the hatchet”. In carrying out the punishment, David must have been torn because of his unwillingness to malign Saul in the past especially in light of his friendship with Jonathan. He specifically protects Jonathan’s son Mephibosheth who is lame and has been accorded special treatment in the king’s palace. David’s willingness listen to the Lord and to root out the cause of the drought and then punish the wrongdoers is to be commended because he averted a far worse disaster.
The second disaster (a plague which killed 70,000) in today’s reading seems harder to understand but is brought on by David’s command to conduct a census. The Bible says that David was incited by Satan although other manuscripts say God’s anger rose up against David to incite him to take a census. Either way God permitted this to happen. The point is that David was setting out on his own without seeking God’s will in the matter. The problem was not that censuses should not be taken In fact many previous censuses had been taken and even proscribed by the Torah. But this particular census was not customary and had no divine initiation. David even received strong counsel against this action but he stubbornly gave the go ahead.
There are two possible reasons why the census was wrong. First, David could have undertaken it to discover how many fighting men were in Israel so he could boast of his sizable army. The second and more probable reason for God’s displeasure was that it was not carried out according to God’s Word in the Torah concerning a census. Exodus says that every male above the age of 20 was supposed to pay a half-shekel ransom. Failure to pay would bring a plague (Exodus 30:12-16). As you recall, David had previously disobeyed the Law when he failed to transport the ark of the covenant according to God’s Law and a Levite was died as a result. So I believe this is the cause of God’s displeasure. God wanted His people (then and now) to fully obey Him in everything.
A final word must be said about the place in Jerusalem where David offered a sacrifice for this census sin. To his credit, he purchased the threshing floor rather than demanding it, which he could have done as king nor did he accept it as a gift from Araunah. He purchased it with his own funds because he wanted it to cost him something personally. This altar becomes the place of the glorious temple that Solomon would build soon after David’s death.